Ugh. That was a hard one to sit through. Annoying format, annoying moderator. (Was a time when Brokaw seemed more engaging.) So much for the idea of a “lively” town hall format. The first debate allowed for a much freer ranging exchange than this one; why not have a few less questions to allow more time for follow-ups? Sigh. Better luck next Wednesday with Bob Schaeffer.
McCain wins for most memorable (& most unfortunate) words of the night, referring to Senator Obama at one point as “that one,” revealing yet again his lack of respect for his opponent.
Grumpy old man was certainly out in force. McCain seemed tired, old, uncomfortable, rambly, verging on cranky. The venue only served to accentuate his tense body language. No doubt McCain’s ripping someone to shreds tonight for his chair being too tall. I kept noticing his perch/lean, which did not look good. And I say that not as a matter of finding fault, but the contrast between his and Obama’s demeanor was striking–and we’ve all learned the hard way these past eight years how much gut reaction drives people’s voting. Of course, McCain doesn’t have the issues to run on either, so he’s in a double bind there.
After a point the whole thing turned into torture by “my friends.” The Wall Street Journal put the count at eighteen. Really, was that all? Maybe it seemed like more because they started coming in swarms later on in the debate. Someone really should tell McCain that phrase is not enough to offset bad or incoherent policy.
More crunching of content to come tomorrow. But curiously, I would say one of the most telling moments of the evening happened beyond the bounds of the debate: if you were watching CSPAN, you would have noticed the usual awkward McCain point-wave-point-handshake-point meet & greet of town hall participants afterwards–and then he and Cindy were gone. And then, Barack and Michelle were still there, for twenty minutes or so (longer? the feed at the theater I was at got cut off), chatting with the crowd, signing autographs, and posing for photos. They were so noticeably relaxed, engaged, and generous with their time, in what had to be a very impromptu situation–and McCain was so very noticeably absent. Mind you, if he’d been there, he’d have been noticeably awkward, so heading out early was probably for the best. But either way, the contrast was striking. I imagine Obama may have won over some of those undecideds just by post-debate performance alone.
Nate chez 538 gives his debate assessment in the larger context:
The sense I had tonight was that McCain was overcoached — that he was trying too hard. I don’t think that he made any significant tactical errors. But he came across as nervous and awkward. And he is longer really fighting on a level playing field. In order to win this election, McCain needed to keep the Republican brand at arm’s-length. He had largely managed to do that until the Lehman Brothers collapse scared the Hell out of Main Street and reminded everyone of the failures of the status quo. McCain needed to empathize on the economy; his “fundamentals” comment made that very difficult. He needed to find some way to position himself in opposition to Senator Obama on the bailout, but he had boxed himself in with his gambit about suspending his campaign. McCain lost tonight, but the reasons for his failure stem from long before this evening.
Sullivan’s debate reaction roundup at the Daily Dish here.
Oh, and now I really want the skinny on Belmont University. I hope fellow 538er Sean, who made the trek to Tennessee, will follow up on this comment he made at the end of live-blogging the debate. Very strong reaction from someone who’s usually so much more even-keeled in his reporting:
By the way, a special shout out for an absolutely horrible experience on the campus of Belmont University. I’m not sure I’ve ever been to a less welcoming place. We hated this campus and the staff here so much that we left to watch the debate at a pizza joint. I don’t like to regret things, but it would be hard to overstate how terrible a day this has been, and how crappy every interaction we had in Tennessee was. It was a terrible decision to leave Indiana and come down here. That had to be said for the record.
Read Full Post »